What happened?
Whilst stored at the Hunter Valley Training Company, 10
metres of the inspection pit below locomotive 3801 had been observed to be
showing signs of collapse with structural failure evident in brickwork and
timber transoms under the locomotive. The tender was leaning 10 degrees and an
observation along the railhead showed twists and dips in what should be a
straight rail. It was only luck that the locomotive didn’t finish up laying on
its side and severely damaged in what was left of the pit. Photos were taken
[some are on the National Trust Australia (NSW) website at http://www.nsw.nationaltrust.org.au/news/bring-back-3801.asp).
It has been known to RailCorp for 9 years that there were
problems with the complex because in 1997 at the Official Commissioning of
Locomotive 3830 a rail was broken in this same complex. During various
“Steamiest” Festivals it had been decided that it was too dangerous
to take 38 Class locomotives into this complex.
What to do?
It was decided to push the locomotive further into the shed,
uncouple the tender and remove it from the shed, remove the damaged rail and
temporarily shore up the pit and rail and hopefully reconnect the tender and
drag the whole locomotive out of the shed, hoping that it will not fall in to
the pit. The locomotive is to be left outside in the weather for an indefinite
period while the damaged track and pit at Hunter Valley Training Company is
being rebuilt.
Will the taxpayers of this State be picking up the bill for
the replacement of HVTC infrastructure. Mr. Ross Bunyon, Chairman of RailCorp
and a Board Member of Hunter Valley Training Company may wish to comment on
this infrastructure upgrading?
Key Points
The locomotive for political reasons had to be taken away
from Eveleigh and 3801 Limited,
The use of the Hunter Valley Training Company at Maitland
appears to be a Labor Party pork barrelling exercise for the struggling seat of
Maitland.
It is now quite evident that those in charge were not fully
experienced in the procedures required to move and safely store this 200 tonne
38 Class locomotive.
It is quite evident that 3801 Limited maintenance staff are
still the only people competent enough to safely look after this locomotive.
Their 20 year record speaks for itself,
It also appears that EPA requirements were never thought
about.
Following complaints about the storage method of the
locomotive, maintenance staff of 3801 Limited were called upon to assist even
though the locomotive is no longer in their control.
Who signed off for
the following?
- Who signed off for sending the
locomotive to East Greta? - Who signed off on this private track
being fit for traffic? - Who signed off a required independent
RailCorp inspection on the HVTC track? - Who signed off on the EPA and OH&S
requirements for HVTC (treated boiler waste water, ash removal, chemical
handling, etc.)
Watch the buck
passing if anyone is prepared to answer these questions.
History
On the night of Monday 27th November 2006, Locomotive 3801
steamed out of Sydney
destined for the Hunter Valley Training Company at Maitland for a mechanical
inspection to determine what overhauling is required for the locomotive. Those
in the know will tell you that it is in near perfect condition other than the
boiler overhaul due in 12 to 18 months providing the current expert maintenance
program can be maintained.
Why to Maitland?
Most of the “expert technical panel” to assess the
locomotives condition come from Melbourne, Sydney or south of Sydney so why not
conduct the inspection at Eveleigh – where facilities including inspection pits
already exist.
Because Maitland is now a swinging seat for the State
election. Needs propping up and the $600,000 grant to the Hunter Valley
Training Company at Maitland is the ultimate pork barreling exercise.
The Government was
not game to send the Locomotive straight to Thirlmere because of voter backlash.
The locomotive was taken to the Hunter Valley Training
Company to be inspected but it was left for 10 days without any of the usual
cleaning and maintenance being carried out. There was ash in the firebox, there
was water in the boiler and tender and essential lubricating of the pistons had
not been carried out. Is this the sign of things to come
On Wednesday 7th December, 3801 Limited were requested to
send maintenance staff to Maitland to carry out work that should have been
carried out a week earlier. Is the staff from 3801 Limited the only people
capable or experienced enough to carry out these operations? And what about the
specially selected RailCorp Experts?
Has HVTS an EPA Authorised ash disposal method in place.
Has HVTS an EPA Authorised waste water treatment plant for
accepting boiler water.
Has HVT$ a Safe Working method approved for wash-outs or
procedures in place for bringing water treatment chemicals on to the site.
Has RailCorp Office of Rail Heritage anybody qualified in
these matters.
Is “Puffing Billy” engineers in charge of the
movement and inspection experienced only on narrow gauge tramway operations and
not main line operations
Was EPA Approval obtained for the emptying of the boiler and
tender this week?
Who at the Hunter Valley Training Company was responsible
for approving the track for use?
Why did the RailCorp team of experts continue to place the
locomotive into the shed
at the HVTC when members were aware that there were problems
with track separation and stress noises noticed?
Why was the
locomotive sent to Maitland when the same inspection could have taken place at
Eveleigh where tested facilities are in place?
This Media Statement
was issued by
Friends of Eveleigh –
saving the great Eveleigh Railway Workshop
All correspondence
to:
The Secretary, FOE, PO Box 381, Belrose West NSW 2085 Phone 0400 441 48